Just like any other choice for pregnancy, birth, and postpartum, it is important to understand both sides before you decide. I have written about what families report and what research says about placenta encapsulation benefits. This post covers the other side: the risks, who may want to skip encapsulation, and how to lower the risks if you choose it.
I am a birth doula and an APPA-trained placenta encapsulation specialist in Oklahoma City, and I believe you deserve an honest answer, even from someone who offers this service.
The quick answer
The main risk of placenta encapsulation is infection, either from bacteria present in the placenta or from unsafe handling. Other possible risks include exposure to heavy metals (especially for people who smoke), medications from your birth, and a possible effect on milk supply. Research on placenta capsules is limited, so these risks are not fully understood. Talk with your midwife or OB before you decide, and if you go ahead, work with a trained specialist who follows strict safety standards.
What is placenta encapsulation?
Placenta encapsulation is a form of placentophagy, which means eating the placenta in any form (Marraccini and Gorman). With the Traditional Method I use, the placenta is cleaned, gently steamed, dehydrated, ground into a fine powder, and placed into capsules. You can read every step in my post on how to encapsulate a placenta.
The risks of placenta encapsulation
1. Infection
Infection is the risk researchers raise most. In 2017, the CDC published a report about a newborn in Oregon who developed a group B strep (GBS) infection. The baby’s parent had been taking placenta capsules, and the same strain of GBS was found in the capsules. The CDC concluded that encapsulation may not remove all infectious bacteria and advised against taking placenta capsules.
Preparation does matter. One study found that common preparation methods “reduce hormone concentrations and bacterial contamination” (Johnson et al.), but reducing bacteria is not the same as removing all of it.
If you develop an infection during labor or right after birth, such as chorioamnionitis (an infection of the membranes), taking your placenta could expose you to that infection again. Viruses such as HIV or hepatitis can also be passed to the people handling the placenta. If you test positive for GBS, have a fever during labor, or have any infection, talk with your provider before your birth and let your specialist know.
2. Heavy metals and other trace elements
The placenta helps protect your baby by holding back some harmful substances, so traces of those substances can remain in it after birth. People who smoke have much higher levels of the heavy metal cadmium in their placentas (Falcón et al.). Eating the placenta could mean taking in the metals your body worked to keep from your baby, and passing them on through breast milk.
For non-smokers, placental cadmium levels are usually low. Families living in areas with heavy pollution can have higher levels of cadmium, lead, and mercury in their placentas (Esteban-Vasallo et al.). This is why encapsulation is generally not recommended if you smoked during pregnancy.
3. Medications from your birth
If you received medications during labor and birth, small amounts may be present in your placenta. Encapsulating it could mean taking in some of those medications again. If you received a lot of medication, ask your provider whether that changes their recommendation.
4. Unsafe handling
Like any food, placental tissue can become contaminated if it is not kept cold or is not prepared safely. This is one of the biggest reasons to work with a trained specialist instead of preparing it yourself. Ask any specialist about their training, whether they have bloodborne pathogens training, and whether they process only one placenta at a time.
5. A possible effect on milk supply
The placenta contains estrogen, and estrogen can suppress prolactin, the hormone that drives milk production. This is the same reason some providers avoid estrogen-containing birth control while a parent is breastfeeding (Hatcher et al.). Some families feel their capsules help their supply, while others worry they could lower it. Research has not answered this either way. If you notice a change in your supply, stop taking your capsules and reach out to your provider or a lactation consultant.
6. Minor side effects
Some families report minor side effects such as headaches or not liking the taste or smell of the capsules. If you ever feel unwell while taking your capsules, stop taking them and contact your provider.
What medical experts say
A 2018 review in the American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology found no scientific evidence of clinical benefit from eating the placenta and recommended that physicians discourage the practice (Farr et al.). That is why I always encourage families to have an honest conversation with their provider. Many providers will still support a family’s choice, and knowing their concerns helps you decide with confidence.
When placenta encapsulation may not be recommended
Encapsulation may not be recommended if:
-
You or your baby develop an infection during labor or right after birth
-
You are diagnosed with chorioamnionitis
-
You smoked during pregnancy
-
Your placenta shows signs of disease, such as placental cancer
If you test positive for GBS, have a fever during labor, or your placenta is sent to pathology, please talk with your provider before your birth and let your specialist know.
How I reduce the risks
If you and your provider decide placenta encapsulation is right for you, here is how I care for your placenta:
-
APPA training, plus bloodborne pathogens training for professional placenta service providers
-
One placenta at a time, so yours is never mixed up with anyone else’s
-
OSHA and bloodborne pathogen standards, with a fully sanitized workspace and equipment
-
The Traditional Method, which steams the placenta before it is dehydrated
-
Clear instructions on keeping your placenta cold until I pick it up, and on storing your capsules
No method can remove every risk, and I will always tell you if something about your birth means encapsulation may not be a good idea.
Questions to ask your provider
Bring these to your next prenatal appointment:
-
Is there anything in my health history that makes placenta encapsulation a poor fit for me?
-
If I test positive for GBS, how would that affect my plans?
-
What would change if I develop a fever or infection during labor?
-
Could placenta capsules interact with any medications or supplements I take?
-
What side effects should I watch for, and when should I stop taking them?
For the full list, including questions for your hospital and your specialist, read should I encapsulate my placenta? Questions to ask your provider.
Frequently asked questions
What are the risks of placenta encapsulation?
The main risk is infection, from bacteria in the placenta or from unsafe handling. Other possible risks include heavy metals, medications from your birth, a possible effect on milk supply, and minor side effects such as headaches.
Can placenta pills make you sick?
They can. The CDC has reported a newborn’s GBS infection linked to placenta capsules that contained the same bacteria. If you feel unwell while taking your capsules, stop taking them and contact your provider.
Can I encapsulate my placenta if I have GBS?
Talk with your provider first. Because of the CDC report, a positive GBS result is an important part of the conversation, and some providers recommend against encapsulation in that case.
Do placenta pills affect milk supply?
We do not know yet. Some families feel their capsules help, and the estrogen in the placenta could in theory lower supply. If you notice a change, stop taking them and talk with your provider or a lactation consultant.
Who should not encapsulate their placenta?
Encapsulation is generally not recommended after an infection during labor or birth, chorioamnionitis, smoking during pregnancy, or if the placenta shows signs of disease. Your provider can help you decide.
Sources
-
Buser, G. L., et al. (2017). Late-onset infant group B streptococcus infection associated with maternal consumption of capsules containing dehydrated placenta, Oregon, 2016. MMWR, CDC.
-
Esteban-Vasallo, M. D., et al. (2012). Mercury, cadmium, and lead levels in human placenta: A systematic review. Environmental Health Perspectives.
-
Falcón, M., et al. (2002). Environmental exposures to lead and cadmium measured in human placenta. Archives of Environmental Health.
-
Farr, A., et al. (2018). Human placentophagy: a review. American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology.
-
Hatcher, R. A., et al. (2011). Contraceptive Technology. AHC Media.
-
Johnson, S. K., et al. (2018). Placenta: worth trying? Human maternal placentophagy: possible benefit and potential risks. Placenta.
-
Marraccini, M. E., and Gorman, K. S. (2015). Exploring placentophagy in humans: Problems and recommendations. Journal of Midwifery & Women’s Health.
Thinking about placenta encapsulation in Oklahoma City?
If placenta encapsulation feels right for you after talking with your provider, I would be honored to be part of your postpartum journey. I serve families across Oklahoma City and Central Oklahoma, pick up your placenta from your birth location, and prepare it with care, one placenta at a time.
Learn about my placenta encapsulation services
If you live outside of Oklahoma, please look for a trained placenta specialist near you who follows strict safety standards.